A walk or easy run can be more than exercise. Leaving some sessions free of calls, scrolling, music, and podcasts may give your attention room to loosen and ideas time to develop. That is a reasonable practice to try—but the research does not prove that a silent walk is always more creative or productive than an audio-supported one.
What the evidence suggests
• In four experiments, Oppezzo and Schwartz found that walking improved divergent thinking—the generation of multiple possible ideas—during and shortly after a walk. It did not improve every kind of thinking: performance on a convergent task requiring one correct answer did not receive the same benefit.
• A 2022 systematic review and multilevel meta-analysis found a positive overall effect of physical-activity interventions on creative ideation. The authors described the field as promising but still developing and called for more rigorous randomized research.
• In a creative-incubation experiment, an undemanding task that allowed more mind wandering improved later performance on previously encountered creativity problems. The task was not walking, and the study did not compare silence with podcasts, but it supports the idea that low-demand mental space can sometimes help ideas incubate.
• A 2024 meta-analysis of 113 acute-exercise studies in healthy young adults found a small overall cognitive benefit, including faster responses and improvements in working memory and inhibition. These laboratory outcomes are related to focused work, but they are not direct measures of workplace productivity.
• Evidence about simply having a smartphone nearby is mixed. A 2023 meta-analysis found a small negative pooled effect on working memory, but null pooled effects for the other cognitive functions studied. That does not establish that carrying a phone—or listening to a podcast—blocks creativity during exercise.
A practical way to use this information
• Try one or two easy, phone-free walks each week, especially when you are developing an idea or working through a problem.
• Keep the pace comfortable enough that movement does not demand all of your attention.
• Before leaving, choose one question to consider. Let your mind wander rather than forcing an answer.
• Record useful ideas after stopping or use a brief voice note only when it is safe to do so.
• Compare quiet sessions with podcast or music sessions. Keep whichever approach helps you think, recover, and remain consistent.
The responsible conclusion
Walking and other physical activity can support creative ideation and may produce small short-term cognitive benefits. Quiet movement may be a useful personal strategy because it removes incoming information and permits mind wandering, but research has not yet shown that phone-free or podcast-free exercise reliably increases real-world productivity.